Skip to main content

MS fatigue questionnaires can give different results

By MS Buddy ·

Summarized from Multiple sclerosis (Houndmills, Basingstoke, England), Nov 2026 · PubMed · DOI. AI-generated summary. Not medical advice.

Observational study · 740 people with MS asked to complete fatigue questionnaires

Research by Jeremy Hobart, David Andrich and 6 colleagues at the University of Plymouth and the University of Western Australia in the United Kingdom, Australia and Switzerland.

Do different MS fatigue questionnaires give the same results?

Key Takeaway

Six fatigue questionnaires gave similar results across groups with MS, but different scores for some individuals.

Six overlapping paper window frames reveal slightly different views of the same muted blue and sage landscape.
Credibility
Interest
Share:1 min read

What They Found

Researchers compared six questionnaires that ask people with MS about fatigue. The questionnaires differed in their questions and structure, and each had strengths and weaknesses. Group results suggested that all six measured the same thing. However, scores differed beyond what measurement error could explain for up to 38% of individuals. The number of questions affected measurement error and how closely individual scores agreed across questionnaires.

Who Should Care and Why

The study involved people with MS who were asked to complete fatigue questionnaires. It focused on measuring fatigue, not treating it. The findings matter to researchers choosing questionnaires for MS studies. They also matter to people developing or using these questionnaires. Similar group results did not mean that different questionnaires gave matching scores for each person.

Important Considerations

This observational study gave questionnaires to 740 people with MS, and 538 responded, about 73%. All six questionnaires had some measurement weaknesses. The study does not establish which questionnaire is best for every purpose.

AI-generated summary — for informational purposes only, not medical advice

Read the original abstract

Published in Multiple sclerosis (Houndmills, Basingstoke, England) by et al.. Reproduced from the PubMed record.

Burdensome fatigue is ubiquitous in multiple sclerosis. Of 18 patient-reported outcome measures used in trials, we shortlisted six of the better-developed according to external criteria and compared their performance and equivalence at item, group and individual person levels. All six instruments were administered to 740 people with MS. Instrument performance was examined using Rasch measurement theory, separately and in a joint analysis, which places all item and person estimates on the same scale. Response rate was 72.7% (n = 538). Instruments differed in content and structure. All combined satisfactory with imperfect measurement characteristics. Item-level analyses (fit, subtests, principal component analyses) and group-level analyses (error-corrected r = 0.85-0.98) implied these instruments measured the same variable. At the person level, instruments generated statistically different estimates for up to 38% of people, depending on instrument item numbers and intercorrelations. Despite item- and group-level analyses implying equivalence, individual-level differences imply that instrument choice matters. This raises concerns regarding our understanding of fatigue and its measurement for any given context. Results highlight the relevance of instrument item number, which influences measurement error associated with individual person estimates and, therefore, the degree to which different patient-reported outcome measures produce statistically equivalent estimates; the value of modern psychometric methods; and should interest anyone choosing, using, developing and analysing patient-reported outcome measure instruments.

The app

Check out the MS Buddy app

It’s free, with no ads. Built by people living with MS.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Related MS research

Two paper stepping-stone paths, one more evenly spaced beside a Pilates mat and blank speech bubbles.
Adding talk therapy to Pilates improved walking in MS

11/20/2026

In a trial of 90 adults with MS, adding fatigue-focused talk therapy to supervised Pilates improved

Read More
Paper bands support a bowl of blue droplets; a few drops sit outside, and a dotted path leads to a guiding hand.
Remotely guided muscle training eased urine leaks in MS

11/20/2026

A review of three trials found remotely guided muscle exercises eased urine leaks and bladder overac

Read More
Two abstract networks of curved blue and clay paths form different connection patterns on an off-white background.
Brain connection changes linked to thinking in early MS

11/20/2026

A small study followed brain connections and thinking in early MS over 10 months. Patterns differed

Read More
Matching walking shoes side by side, one on a home rug and one on an exercise mat, in navy and ochre.
Home exercise matched facility exercise for MS walking

11/19/2026

In a study of 379 people with MS and walking difficulties, home and facility exercise had similar wa

Read More
A winding blue paper path curves around ochre shapes toward a resting circle bordered by an incomplete paper ring.
MS fatigue may reflect extra effort to control movement

11/17/2026

A review suggests MS fatigue may reflect extra effort to control movement and incomplete recovery af

Read More
Two paper patchwork circles have similar overall colors but different pieces, with folds hiding or revealing layers.
Computer studies show MS fatigue surveys differ by person

11/16/2026

Computer studies found MS fatigue surveys can give similar group results but different individual sc

Read More

Not all studies carry the same weight: sample size, study design and whether results were replicated all matter. The credibility score above reflects the journal, and the original paper is linked under More Details. Read how MS Buddy selects and scores research, and talk to your MS care team before acting on any study.